Friday, 31 May 2013

A Dark Night In Gotham - Batman Miniatures Game & Review

Well, I've finally managed to get a game of the Batman Miniatures Game. I'll present this as a battle report rather than a review initially, and then sum up my thoughts about the game itself at the end.

For simplicity's sake Matt and I decided to play the game without the variables of objectives, street lights, sewer entrances and strategies. We rolled up the Patrol scenario in which both sides are trying to get to the opposite corner of the board from their deployment zone. Our gangs had the unusual reputation of about 180.

Matt was using his SWAT miniatures from his own Flashbang game as Commissioner Gordon (in the suit with the pistol) and Officers Alpha (MG), Bravo (Sniper Rifle/Shotgun) and Delta (Hand Gun & Invisible Riot Shield). He also used his available funds to equip provide flash-lights and handcuffs to his men.

As Matt was running cops, I broke out the Joker, his main squeeze Harley Quinn and the only henchman in town, Two-Gun Turk. As the rulebook was particularly confusing on the additional equipment for Joker's gang, I simply bought more ammo for Turk. I also used Joker's Kaos Agent rule to reduce the game from the standard 6 turns to five, putting the pressure on both sides to get moving.

Aware that the Joker is on the loose, Gordon and Bravo move carefully through the poorly lit (no street lights, remember?) streets.

Further down the block, Delta and Alpha move up in support, keeping their eyes peeled for the Clown Prince of Crime.

Meanwhile, Harley Quinn and Turk make a run to across the street on another absurd errand for the Giggling Godfather...

...who waits in his warehouse lair, laughing maniacally, as he is wont to do.

The police continue to carefully search the buildings and alleyways for the dangerous fugitive.

Suddenly, a high pitched giggle and flash of red and white draw the cops attention down the darkened street.

Harley and Turk dive into the cover of a warehouse, whilst next door Gordon and Bravo are distracted by a chattering sound; their eyes are drawn to the curious sight of some clockwork teeth slowly making their way across the road towards them...BOOOOOM!

The windows of the building are blown inwards, showering the cops with glass, injuring Bravo. Alpha and Delta run up towards the sound of the blast on the other side of the street.

With the cops distracted, Harley slips through a window and makes a run for it whilst Turk lies in wait the ambush the flatfoots.

Gordon staggers out of the smoke and into the doorway of the warehouse and a furious but ineffectual fire fight ensues as he and Turk blaze away at each other, mainly splintering wood (it turns out that we were playing the Blink! rules wrong and so cover was far too effective. Suddenly, a booming shot rings out from the warehouse across the street and Gordon crumples to the floor wrapped in multi-coloured streamers (Joker's one shot gun should actually have taken him out of the game on a critical, but again, we played it wrong and just had Gordon incapacitated).

The cops rush to where the shot came from, hoping to corner the assassin.

Meanwhile, on the other side of town, Harley Quinn finally reaches to Joker's real target and stashes a small, but highly explosive device in a skip owned by an important player in Gotham's underworld, the detonation of which at an opportune moment is likely to cause chaos.

The cops continue to hunt Gordon's assailant and stumble upon the Joker's hideout. Can they apprehend the Clown Prince of Crime?

Another flurry of shots ring out as the struggling Gordon is hit again, this time by real bullets, as the forgotten Turk takes revenge for the three years he spent in Blackgate. Gordon slumps into unconciousness.

With the cops closing in, Joker slips out the back, one of the SWAT team briefly has a shot on his purple clad form, but he disappears chuckling into the night. Another mad scheme well under way...

When it came to counting up victory points, we had both managed to infiltrate the other's deployment zone, but the game was won by the taking down of Gordon. And so on to the review:

  • It feels like Batman - Joker's rather impressive range of abilities puts him in the roll of mastermind calling the shots, Harley skips and somersaults her way around the board and the cops do cop things (even calling in a searchlight from air support - which Matt forgot to use)
  • I like the dark - the light rules are a nice variation to the standard skirmish and give some credence to the short ranges, adding in street lights will really strengthen ranged weapons and the way that flash lights work is a nice touch. Characters who can see in the dark are at a big advantage
  • It's short and to the point - just a handful of turns really puts the pressure on and raises the stakes
  • Tactical thinking - the mini battle-boards are a nice touch, having to plan ahead (unless you're the Joker) makes you have to consider your options; which are many thanks to the range of abilities each character has
  • Team building - the flexibility in creating a gang already allows for a big range of strategies, do you go for a swarm of henchmen, opt for a bruiser like Killer Croc, or go for someone more subtle like The Riddler
  • The game flows - once you're playing pretty much everything becomes fairly intuitive very quickly, despite the apparent complexity, it's an easy game to play once you've started
  • It's Batman - seriously, the massive advantage this has over other similar skirmish games is that I know and care about the characters and can happily invent narrative on the fly, this is something games like Malifaux and Warmachine (which I am assured are very good games in their own right) will never have for me

  • The rulebook - seriously, this needs work. I know that it's translated from Spanish, but at least get an English speaker to give it the once over before publication as there are numerous instances of skills having different names, clauses being missed out, words not being effectively translated and all in all it takes a couple of reads and a bit of detective work to puzzle some bits out
  • The scenarios - I know the game is nominally based on Arkham City and gang wars, but that's not really Batman to most folk. The scenarios are a bit bland and even. Some more fun capers like robberies, kidnappings and doomsday devices would really add some colour to proceedings.
  • Lack of a campaign structure - you may have worked out that I like narrative. I'd like for skirmishes to matter in some way beyond bragging rights and the inevitable tournaments and ultimate combos, although flawed, Necromunda is still the standard setter for this kind of structure and so I'll probably end up cobbling something together of my own using that structure
  • It's a little token heavy - I may need to find a way around that, Matt and I were already using black and red dice for stuns and injuries

All in all, I like the game, and the things that I don't like are largely due to this seemingly being an early draft. Matt like the game too, and I've already furnished him with some spare Heroclix I had no plans for to allow Batman and Robin to join his cops and the Joker to team up with the Scarecrow, Mr Freeze and some henchmen.

I'd really recommend giving these rules a spin as there's a lot to like. Due to Knight Models' free downloads, you don't have to use their models to play. I'm going to be sticking with this game for my Gotham project for the foreseeable future and my enthusiasm for it has prompted me to get some more stuff painted which you'll see more of in the coming days. 


  1. Kieron -

    I had a couple of reactions while reading your review on which I want to hear your opinion. First though, thank you for taking the time to do your review. These are very helpful when deciding to put out the hard cash on product.

    First, I love Batman as well and I have a lot of heroclix bats figs. I thought, "...yeah, just get the rules and use my Bats clix, I'm set." It seems that the only reason I'd go after the figs is, well, for the awesome sculpts. Your thoughts?

    Second, I apologize for this one as it may seem waaay left field, it was triggered by a general line of thinking on my part looking to these kinds of games and your emphasizing narrative in your skirmishing/wargaming descriptions (now that I think about it, it fits in your Cheaphammer theme as well [great name BTW]). I am a Champions (Hero Games) player from long ago. Hero Games has always impressed me as being the most outright wargame like RPG of the lot, that never intended to be such. I tend to have this reaction when assessing any skirmish/wargame in which I want to involve myself (currently looking at Guild Ball as well). It seems that I could take Hero Games and create a skirmish scenario in an setting I wish and have narrative possibilities like only an RPG can provide - instead of playing skirmish/wargames. Your thoughts?


    1. Since writing this, I've played a lot more BMG and the rulebook has been improved. However some of my criticisms regarding narrative play stand.

      I'm not familiar with Hero System but I'm sure you could get the outcome you want. Another suggestion might be 7TV which might make for very simple narrative play.

      BMG is definitely still a skirmish wargame, and things like objectives are integral. If you want something narrative, at the moment, other solutions are likely to be better.

      Hope that helps.

  2. Thank you for the feedback! I'll look into the 7TV.